Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigation. Show all posts

Friday, May 27, 2016

Beware the 'Sunk Cost Trap'

The ' Sunk Cost Trap' is a concept that interests me because it helps to explain behaviour that causes us to cling to something because of our investment of time, effort or money in it rather than to cut our losses and move on.

According to Investopedia, the 'Sunk Cost Trap' is the tendency of people to irrationally follow through on an activity that is not meeting their expectations because of the investment of time and/or money they have already spent on it.

Although an economic concept, the Sunk Cost Trap is also a psychological phenomena and applies to many aspects of life including dispute resolution. It causes individuals to stay the course or even invest more time and money in a bad decision or course of action in a futile effort to make their initial decision seem worthwhile.

In mediation, we often hear the plea that " I might as well go to court. I have nothing to lose as I have already spent $60,000 on it, why would I give up now". Of course, if it was the wrong decision in the first place then throwing more money or time at it will simply make it worse.

The rationale behind it is that we have a genuine interest in making our efforts worth our while and even if we consider our efforts, time or money spent to be in vain,we are reluctant to abandon them.

Somehow we believe that by continuing , we can recover sunk costs but the reality is that they are gone and we can't.

Similarly in life, it would be like persisting with an unfulfilling job just because we had invested so much time in it or a country persisting with a war so the lives already lost are not wasted.

Allowing ourselves to admit mistakes and move on is far better than entrenching ourselves in a situation just to save face.

The fact that we have already invested a lot in legal costs can never be a good reason for persisting in going to court if the better decision  in the circumstances is to cut our losses. Cutting our losses, means admitting that we have made a mistake  and we all find this hard to do but ultimately it may be the more productive decision.

For all inquiries about the benefits of Mediation phone us at Brisbane Mediations on 07) 38397400 or visit our website www.brisbanemediations.com.au. You will be pleased you did!!

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Diversity in Practice.


One of the best things about mediating is the diversity of cases and personalities you deal with on an almost daily basis.

Not unlike legal practice, there is an ever changing array of individual  situations and circumstances however whilst legal practice is conducted against an adversarial backdrop or "civilised warfare" as one barrister aptly described it, mediation enables you to work with the parties to facilitate a solution. Indeed, it is often or usually the disadvantages of litigation that cause parties to embrace a mediated outcome with the obvious benefits that flow.

Another significant difference is that in legal practice you are confronted with on-going files some of which remain current  for months and years. In mediation, whether successful or not, you can close the file and bid the parties goodbye at the end of the day. After decades of legal practice, I find this aspect of mediation very attractive, particularly where parties have found a solution and can move on.

I find however, at least at this stage that it is still handy to retain some contact with the coal face of practice and for this reason I have accepted a consultancy role at Reardon Family Lawyers of Southport.

Driving down to Southport this morning  provided time to ponder these issues. I must say that I  enjoy the opportunity to chew the fat with David and his team about cases they are presently involved in. It is good not to have the ongoing pressures and stresses of  running a practice but at the same time to retain some of the benefits that a link with practice provides. David's positive attitude to practice is refreshing as is the obvious desire he and his team have to achieve an acceptable outcome for his clients in an efficient and cost effective manner.. I am happy to endorse their approach.

Tomorrow it will be back to mediating at Brisbane Mediations for me whilst Reardon Family lawyers will motor on at the coast.

I feel fortunate to have the diversity that mediation and a limited involvement in practice provide and look forward to my days at the coast as time goes by.

For those in need of a referral, Reardon Family Lawyers can be contacted on 5527 0676 and of course Brisbane Mediations on 3839 7400.

Sunday, December 13, 2015

Family Law in Crisis.

According to The Australian of 11 December 2015, independent Senators John Madigan and David Leyonhjelm are among a group of senators who have called for a "root-and-branch review" of the family law system. Senator Madigan has been pushing for a radical overview of the system to make it less adversarial in nature, arguing the current system is causing "inexcusable damage" to children.
Senator Madigan urged the government to "adequately resource the court to deal with things in a more expedient manner and have people in it who are properly trained".
He said "the court needs to be better resourced than what it is and people operating in the area of family law need to be trained in this area".
Senator Madigan also wanted to see the court operate in a way that brought families together , rather than "blew them apart".
Senator Leyonhjelm said: "You can't expect a court system to operate for the benefit of the public if they have to wait extended periods of time because there aren't enough judges. That's a no -brainer."

Clearly the court has a resource problem.However good steps in reducing the current pressure would be to refer more matters to mediation, particularly those with modest pools and to introduce compulsory mediation of property matters before parties are able to initiate court proceedings.
It will be interesting to see how far the independent senators get with their call for "root-and -branch review".

Wednesday, December 9, 2015

Travel to Mediation

It was pleasant yesterday to travel to Ipwich to conduct a mediation involving both property and children's issues.

Parties often don't realise that mediators are usually prepared to travel to suit the convenience of the parties.

In this case both parties lived in the vicinity of Ipswich and both legal representatives were based in Ipswich.

Sometimes depending on distance, some charge may be made for travelling time, however with the mediation being convened as close by as Ipswich, it was easy to make a decision to waive any charge for travelling time and mileage.

While it is always good to have the facilities on offer at our usual rooms on Wickham Terrace, in this instance a decision was made for the mediation to proceed at the chambers of local barristers and the rooms and facilities more than sufficed.

The gesture of chambers to provide lunch was greatly appreciated and the sandwiches both plentiful and well received by the parties, their representatives and of course the mediator.

At Brisbane Mediations we often travel to undertake mediation and are always happy to consider a request to do so.

Not only did the day provide a welcome change to our normal routine but I am pleased to report that with the help of both representatives, the parties were able to reach agreement on all issues.

As they say, in the usual parlance, a successful day was had by all.

The father's solicitor will now prepare consent orders which the representatives will jointly submit to the court for approval.

With the Court's approval almost guaranteed due to the reasonableness of the agreement reached, the parties are a long way in front in terms of legal costs and avoiding the long delays that are an everyday feature of a court system that is quite simply breaking under the load.

I look forward to the next opportunity to travel into the regions to assist parties to resolve their dispute.

Why not invite us out to your place for your next mediation.

Thursday, October 1, 2015

One Barrister's Perspective on Settlement.

In recent days, while attending a function at the Family Court, I chatted with a barrister whom I knew well, about his work generally and the state of the list in the Brisbane Registry.

The barrister who enjoys a strong reputation in Family Law remarked that he hadn't done a trial in ages. " All of my matters seem to settle before trial, many of them at mediation ", he said.

When pressed further as to why this was so, the barrister volunteered that apart from the obvious issue of costs and parties not being able to afford to go to trial, it was the uncertainty of the outcome that was also a factor. Clients regularly ask me whether I can guarantee them a better outcome if they go to trial and inevitably the answer is " no I can't " he said.

The costs issue is self evident and this combined with the uncertainty of outcome, make up what lawyers and mediators refer to as the risk factor which in most cases is a strong deterrent to parties proceeding to trial.

Wednesday, June 24, 2015

Flexibility of Mediation

One of the many advantages of mediation is it's flexibility. In fact it can be convened anywhere and anytime and without the inevitable delays of the court process.
Earlier this week, we conducted a mediation where one of the parties attended by phone from Victoria. The same process applied with each party participating in a one hour confidential intake followed by a four hour mediation with capacity to extend.
The intake,whether by phone or in person,helps in establishing the necessary rapport and trust which are often the basis for a successful outcome.
It is not uncommon at Brisbane Mediations for one or both parties to attend by phone or Skype. While this is usually essential in International matters, it also helps reduce costs where a party is interstate or some distance from Brisbane.
In fact there is no reason why Queensland mediators can't offer the phone option to attract work from other capitals or outlying centres.
Our capable staff will be happy to respond to any enquiries at resolve@brisbanemediations.com.au. For further information see our website www.brisbanemediations.com.au

Monday, March 2, 2015

Brisbane Mediations-Current Availability

Denise Britton and I, the principals of Brisbane Mediations are currently travelling in South America and will be away from Brisbane until late March.
Over the past week, we have attended the South West Medico Legal conference in Beunos Aires.
Buenos Aires is an interesting city and perhaps aspects are the subject of another blog. The city like the whole of Argentina is facing serious economic problems and the threat of the currency collapsing.
While we are away the office of Brisbane Mediations continues to be staffed by our able assistants, Joanne McDonald and Krystina Jones who are available to handle enquiries and accept bookings.
Joanne and Krystina can accept bookings for after our return to Brisbane or direct enquiries to experienced Mediators on our panel.
Whatever the type of dispute we have mediators to handle it.
Some of our more experienced mediators include Tom Stodulka, James White, Donna Cooper, Gary Shepherd, Sue Waterman, Fran Conway. Of course there are many others and Joanne and Krystina can recommend a mediator to suit your particular dispute.
Anyone wishing to email me directly can do so at either mike@emfl.com.au or resolve@brisbanemediations.com.au
I am happy to discuss my availability for dates in April, as of course is Denise.
We both value your enquiries and support for our business and will respond as soon as possible.
Please check our website, www.brisbanemediations.com.au
We look forward to assisting you to resolve your dispute without the cost and delay of litigation.

Mike Emerson

Sunday, February 8, 2015

Trust pays Dividends in Mediation

As a lawyer practising in the family jurisdiction over many years, I have often explained to clients that "transparency means trust" when litigating. Failure to disclose or deliberate deceitfulness is likely to impact on the other party's ability or willingness to negotiate during settlement attempts.

Trust is also vitally important in mediation. As with litigation, transparency assists parties to negotiate and reach a resolution.

Parties to mediation must also trust the process and the mediator if resolution chances are to be optimised.

The mediation intake plays a most important role in developing trust - both in the process and the mediator.  It provides an opportunity for the mediator to explain his or her independence and neutrality and the mediator's role.

Most importantly, however, through careful listening, eye contact and a genuine interest in what parties say, mediators are able to establish rapport and develop trust. This rapport and trust Is an investment by the mediator which can produce big dividends in terms of results should the going gets tough later in the mediation.  

Clearly trust in it's many facets is important to mediation success.




Thursday, January 29, 2015

A Spirit of Compromise in Mediation. Hindsight is a wonderful thing!

A spirit of compromise is essential in achieving an outcome in mediation.

Mediation has gained popularity because courts have failed to provide inexpensive and timely outcomes for disputing parties.

Mediation can be convened quickly, is less expensive (often vastly so), and enables parties to move on with their lives without undue delay.

Success at Mediation is greatly assisted by proper disclosure and transparent dealings.  A spirit of compromise - including willingness to listen to the other party's views and acknowledgment that court outcomes are discretionary and usually encompass a range of possible outcomes- improves prospects of resolution.

Some time ago we undertook a mediation intake for a party who chose not to proceed with the mediation but rather to embark on litigation, confident in his solicitor's advice that a particular favourable outcome would be achieved.

Later, on returning to mediation on a peripheral issue, the same party expressed considerable lament that he had not continued to mediate in the first instance. After he and the other party had each spent approximately $150,000, he had been told by the same solicitor 'at the door of the court' that, "Today is the day we compromise our position to try to achieve a settlement".

Whilst the solicitor was no doubt confident in his original advice, the client would have been better served by exploring a range of possible outcomes at mediation and compromising to achieve an outcome both parties could accept. They could then have moved on emotionally earlier and the money spent on litigation would have been available to fund the more wholesome needs of themselves and their children.

Hindsight is such a wonderful thing!

Sunday, July 20, 2014

Ethics and Negotiation

Whilst researching a paper on ethics and mediation, I came across an interesting decision of the State Administrative Tribunal in Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee v Fleming [2006] WASAT 352.

The decision involved a complaint about a practitioner sent to the Tribunal by the West Australian Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee, that the practitioner was guilty of unprofessional conduct, in that in the course of professional communications with another practitioner, he made representations to the other practitioner which were, to his knowledge, misleading.

By way of background, the Australian Solicitors Conduct Rules ( ASCR ) which commenced to apply in Queensland on 1 June 2012 now provide a framework for ethical conduct by solicitors in their daily practice. A breach of these Rules is capable of constituting unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct and may give rise to disciplinary action by the relevant regulatory authority which in Queensland is of course the Legal Services Commission ( LSC).

The conduct complained of in the West Australian instance, could well now be subject of a complaint to the LSC if it arose in Queensland.

The interesting aspect of the West Australian decision was that the conduct complained of occurred in the course of settlement negotiations and communication between the two practitioners.

The Tribunal found the practitioner's conduct unprofessional and further found it was no answer to the complaint that the practitioner was merely acting on his client's instructions. In holding as it did, the Tribunal emphasised the importance of practitioner's acting ethically in settlement negotiations stating inter alia as follows :

At paragraph 74, "....just as in litigation a practitioner may not use dishonest or unfair means or tactics to hinder his opponent in the conduct of his case ( D'Orta-Ekenaike v Victoria Legal Aid (2005) 223 CLR 1 at [111], per McHugh J ), so he ought not do so in other areas of practice. Arguably perhaps for a number of reasons, the proscription against such conduct is more important in settlement negotiations. "

And at paragraph 76, " Honesty, fairness and integrity are also of importance in such negotiations because they are conducted outside the court and are beyond the control which a judge hearing the matter might otherwise exercise over the practitioners involved. Outside the trial process,there is no impartial adjudicator to " find the truth" between the opposing assertions. Dishonest or sharp practice by the practitioner to secure an advantage for his client might go undetected for some considerable time or for all time. A level of trust between the advisers involved is therefore essential".

For the same reasons these principles and cautions would also apply to mediation.Clearly the duties of fairness and honesty owed to the court in relation to the conduct of litigation are also owed to practitioners in other areas of practice.

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Flexibility in Mediation

The American Bar association has recognised "flexibility" as one of the factors defining high quality mediation practice.

The finding is one of the factors identified by the Association in it's published Final Report-Task Force on Improving Mediation Quality.

While it is good to have some recognizable steps or standardisation in mediation process, the mediator needs to be ever mindful of the range of approaches and tools in his or her skillset and try to identify what may or may not work in a particular dispute.

An example of this arose in an elder law mediation we undertook last week where an 80 plus lady was involved in a family dispute with allegations that one of her children had taken advantage of her to enrich himself.The parties were embroiled in District Court litigation over a jointly owned property of reasonably modest value and the prospect that if not resolved, the dispute would further lessen the net value of the property in dispute and accentuate the divisions in what was already a highly divided family.

During the shuttle discussions it became apparent that the son was prepared to compromise his claim  for compensation for work allegedly undertaken on the property, however his mother had reached a hard nosed position and was intent on taking all,despite the fact that this would involve a costly and messy trial with the possibility of no real winner.

Rather than follow the customary steps, a heavy emphasis and lots of time was spent in listening to and validating elderly mum's concerns and developing a rapport which proved invaluable in gently guiding her to what was clearly a sensible and commonsense solution of  a  complicated fact situation with various allegations and counter allegations many of which would be difficult to prove.

Whilst the path of the process was not clearly apparent when we set out and evolved as we moved through the dispute, I as the mediator, have no doubt that the armchair chat type approach and heavy investment in rapport and trust was the right one for this dispute and resulted in an outcome where the parties not only saved significant costs, but were able to take up the threads of communication in a manner suggesting at least some prospect however small, of family healing so that the elderly mother could possibly have some chance of finding harmony and peace in her twilight years.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Mediation and Court delays

One reason for using mediation is that unlike the court process, a mediation can be convened at any time to suit the parties.

Trials have become a very expensive process with courts under resourced and serious court delays resulting.These days it is not unusual for disputing parties to have to wait for a year or more to get a hearing.Particularly in the relationship area this is most unsatisfactory with parties having to put their lives on hold while they await a hearing.Sometimes it is necessary for properties to be revalued and other circumstances can change significantly.

Delays in getting a hearing are only part of the problem however as even after a final hearing parties often have to wait long periods for a decision.Courts do their best to avoid these delays, but they inevitably occur.As recently as last weekend there was a report in the Brisbane Courier Mail detailing delays in the Family Court and Federal Magistrates Court and the inpact they were having.

Mediation offers parties in dispute the opportunity to resolve their dispute without these delays.Mediation can be convened with little notice and scheduled quickly.Consequently because of the high success rate of mediation, parties often resolve their disputes without the delays associated with court proceedings.Apart from being organised quickly, there is no waiting for an outcome, as if parties are able to reach a resolution, then they usually leave with an agreement which can be formalised in a court order.

Parties can access a mediation through their lawyer or approach a mediation agency directly.Some mediation agencies have waiting lists, however private mediation services can usually schedule mediations at short notice and of course with these services lawyers are usually welcome to attend so the parties have ready access to their legal advice in the course of the mediation.At Brisbane Mediations, we have over 30 mediators on our panel so there are no delays in scheduling mediations and lawyers are always welcome.In fact we generally find that lawyers are very helpful in achieving an outcome at the mediation.

The ability to convene mediations at short notice is one of the distinct advantages of mediation.Furthermore mediation has the flexibility of not having to be convened within court hours and the saving to the parties both in terms of costs and emotional distress is enormous.

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Court delays and mediation

A recent article in the legal affairs section of the Australian highlights the advantage of mediation in offering a speedy and readily available solution to people in conflict.


The article in The Australian on Friday 28 October 2011 outlined concern over delayed judgments in the Brisbane registry of the Federal Magistrates Court coinciding with a surge in the court's workload.


Although the Federal Magistrates Court deals with the majority of family law matters a shortage of magistrates is said to have led to extensive delays in the Bribane registry.


President of the Queensland Family Law Practitioners Association Deborah Awyzio is quoted as saying that the biggest problem associated with the delays in Brisbane was that parties awaiting judgment "essentially have to put their lives on hold".


One of the advantages of mediation is that it can be undertaken at any time and you don't have to wait for a court to be available to hear your dispute.


Whereas court proceedings are often drawn out which increases the costs, mediation can be organised and implemented quickly and usually completed in a day.If people reach agreement they can avoid the long delays in court judgments being delivered.


At mediation a person is able to present his or her case and hear the other person's version at an early stage of the matter and the process allows for commercial or lateral solutions which may not otherwise be available.


The whole process can be organised and "done and dusted" quickly, enabling the parties to avoid the delay and uncertainty and above all the cost of court proceedings.


Mike Emerson
Co-Principal Brisbane Mediations

Monday, October 31, 2011

Mediation and Relationships

One of the advantages of Mediation is that it is less likely to harm on-going relationships than litigation. This is particularly important where people in dispute need to maintain an ongoing relationship - commercial arrangements between suppliers and customers; parenting relationships between separated parents who have parenting responsibilities to fulfil; or working relationships between co-workers who have clashed in the workplace.
Mediation is a process where disputing parties enlist the assistance of a neutral person (the mediator) to help identify issues in dispute and explore options and alternatives to reach an agreement that will accommodate their respective needs.
Litigation on the other hand involves parties using courts to review opposing factual versions of disputes and provide a decision based on the evidence provided by each side (in their affidavits or stories) of the dispute. The decision almost always effectively endorses one view of a case and rejects the other and often costs are awarded to the successful party, effectively punishing the other.
Litigation by its very nature highlights and accentuates differences – as presented in affidavits and as each counsel cross examines the other party to expose weaknesses in their version of events. Mediation , on the other hand, looks for common ground and strives for agreement.
Litigation encourages a winner take all approach whereas Mediation looks for a win/win outcome.
Considerable damage can be done to on-going personal relationships (for example, between parents or between beneficiaries under a will) where one person, in seeking to have his or her version accepted, has to try to destroy the other person’s case. Similarly, in the commercial field, time in court is highly unlikely to engender an ongoing relationship - particularly when at the end of the day one party is the victor and the other the vanquished, left to pick up the pieces.
When a result is imposed by a court, one party may leave the court room happy and the other disgruntled and bitter. Evidence given during the trial has most likely eroded the previous relationship even more and increased the chance that these two parties will struggle indefinitely to relate into the future –personally or commercially as the case may be.
At Mediation , however, seemingly warring parties often shake hands or communicate in a genial manner at the end of the day, with a copy of the signed agreement in hand as they head off. A result has been reached by consensus rather than by the imposition of a decision by a stranger. Dignity has been maintained and the vestiges of a relationship remain intact with a chance of enrichment in the future. In the commercial arena there is every chance that the parties will continue their mutually beneficial relationship, particularly where they have found a solution which ultimately takes account of and accommodates the needs (often different from the wants) of each.
It is easy to see why Mediation is often said to involve a saving, not only in material costs, but also in costs to relationships.

Mike Emerson

Co-Principal Brisbane Mediations

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Australia World Leader with Mandatory Mediation in Family Law Parenting Disputes

Los Angeles Attorney, Mark Baer, has praised Australian reforms in Family Law whilst expressing concerns about recent Californian legislation likely to increase time, expense and the adversarial nature of Family Law matters. According to Mr Baer, "It's time for our (USA) government to affect (sic) a reform in the family law system to shift the emphasis from litigation, as the dominant practice, to mediation ... Litigation is not only more expensive but it is also more damaging to the family system which still has to maintain contact and function, to some extent, when there are children involved." Mr Baer comments on the British introduction from 6 April 2011 of a requirement for divorcing couples in England and Wales to undergo mediation for both parenting and financial issues before being allowed to access the courts. He points out that this reform follows the Australian example. In Australia, except in certain exceptional circumstances, Registered Family Dispute Resolution Practitioners must issue Certificates indicating that parties have attempted to resolve their parenting disputes at mediation before an application can be made for intervention by either the Family Court or Federal Magistrates Court. Denise Britton - Co-Principal, Brisbane Mediations http://mwne.ws/gMJI0f